Where are the insurers, yet again....
I've been
asking this question since 2008, when ZIRP took down insurance and pension funds INTENTIONALLY. Why were the insurers silent? They're a HUGE and RICH industry, with plenty of lobbyists and influence. They specialize in quantifying and predicting. They understand compound interest and exponential curves better than anyone else. They avoid bad models and stupid assumptions, because bad models are unprofitable. Profit comes from
agreeing with reality, which makes insurance the most realistic and scientific of all industries. But they allowed ZIRP to continue forever.
This article by a RETIRED actuary compares the AIDS panic with this year's "virus" holocaust. He gets everything right, with an insider perspective.
Best of all, he doesn't play the stupid
People can't estimate risk game.
In both cases the virus was largely confined to specific populations, and EVERYONE KNEW IT. There was never any reason to assume "equal opportunity". Viruses are specialists.
I spent the next several months developing mathematical models of the spread of infection, and applying them to official health statistics, which were provided under free subscription by the Centers for Disease Control in their Weekly Surveillance Report. And, like anyone who has worked with epidemiological models during an emerging infection, I came to understand that early-stage projections are not neutral; they have an intrinsic and marked tendency towards exaggeration of whatever threat they’re applied to.
The reason is that with any new health condition, early infections and deaths naturally occur among the most susceptible parts of the population. With AIDS, there were clearly-defined and relatively small groups of people who were at very high risk, and almost all of the early cases were among members of those groups. As the disease spread to the much larger lower-risk parts of the population, overall rates of infection and death fell significantly.
When unrepresentative infection and death rates derived from early data are projected into the far future their effects are greatly amplified, just as a rifle fired at a distant target will turn a tiny error in aim into a miss by miles. And once the projected rates have been translated into numbers of deaths for a population of millions we end up with apocalyptic forecasts that can’t help but induce panic.
Many scientists spend their careers searching for eye-catching results, and it must be extremely difficult to choose to tone down the few that do occur, especially when they apply to a novel and high-profile disease. The temptation to believe you’ve discovered a genuinely awful and important truth is a powerful one. The Royal College of Nursing certainly couldn’t resist: in 1985, they predicted that one million people in Britain would have AIDS within six years. But by 1990, the cumulative total was less than 5,000.
In both cases the insurers knew that the
EXPONENTIAL projections were wrong and destructive, but they didn't step up to resist.
ANY TIME YOU HEAR AN EXPERT CLAIMING THAT A NATURAL PHENOMENON IS EXPONENTIAL, YOU KNOW INSTANTLY AND PERFECTLY AND TAUTOLOGOUSLY THAT THE CLAIM IS WRONG AND THE EXPERT IS A MURDEROUS CRIMINAL. NATURE IS NOT CAPABLE OF DOING EXPONENTIALS.
Silence can't be good for profits. In 1980, and even more now after Romneycare, insurers are the main payers for medical care. When projections are wrong, insurers will spend more for unneeded tests and appointments for people who really didn't need to worry. And in the current holocaust insurers will end up spending HUGELY more for serious cancer treatment, which would have been cheaper if caught early.
I'm glad THIS actuary (RETIRED) chose to use his SKILL to clarify the situation.
But the question remains: Why didn't the insurance companies speak out IMMEDIATELY at the time when their authority and lobbying could have made a difference? They could have saved a whole lot of expense for themselves, and could have saved MILLIONS of lives in the current holocaust.
For insurers, profit and saving lives are PARALLEL goals. In earlier decades insurers often lobbied for regulations to improve safety and health. Home and business insurers have always helped customers avoid theft and fire and other hazards. Auto safety regulations were started by an
insurance-financed research project in 1956. Fuckhead Nader managed to put his brand on the project for self-aggrandizement, but it was really a cooperative effort by insurers and universities.
Labels: Leth, Real World Math
Where are the insurers 2
What happened to insurance companies? Been asking this in various contexts, especially
ZIRP/NIRP and Romneycare. Insurers could easily see the disastrous consequences of both policies FOR THEIR OWN BOTTOM LINE, but did nothing to stop them.
Here are two more.
= = = = =
1. After the Chicago Fire, insurance companies got together and forced cities to improve building codes and fire departments. Result: tremendous saving of lives and property in the next 100 years AND more profit for insurers.
Where are the insurers on modern fire problems? Bad government forest management has led to huge losses of property and lives. Emergency information is completely missing, building codes don't require metal or brick siding, and governments continue to commit arson.
= = = = =
2. In the '50s, insurance companies got tired of paying for unnecessary deaths in car crashes. They
organized research to improve car safety, and forced governments to require seat belts, padded dashes, etc. Result: tremendous saving of lives AND more profit for insurers.
Where are the insurers on deaths caused by medical errors? Recent news has repeated a fact known for 10 years: Medical errors kill far more than smoking or car crashes.
= = = = =
The often quoted
What's good for GM is good for America is used inversely. In context, Engine Charlie Wilson meant that GM succeeds when America succeeds. But
What's good for insurers is good for America is exactly true as stated. When insurers remove a threat to their bottom line, lots of American lives are saved.
Low skill?
I'm puzzled by the recent behavior of insurance companies.
They were somewhat dubious about Romneycare but supported it anyway.
They haven't lobbied against ZIRP which DESTROYS them.
Now that the consequences of Romneycare are becoming more clear, insurers are backing out fast. [Specifically: When you have to cover everyone, you have to charge huge premiums. Many people and companies are simply unable to pay huge premiums, so they go without insurance. Cranking up the penalty won't help if the money ISN'T THERE.]
Both decisions are puzzling because
estimating the future risk of financial decisions is EXACTLY THEIR BUSINESS. This is WHAT INSURERS DO FOR A LIVING.
GM would catch the meaning of a Federal prohibition of automobiles. Intel would understand the consequences of a 100% sales tax on integrated circuits. They would lobby ferociously and successfully against such proposals.
Why did insurers allow ZIRP to happen? Why did they take 6 years to see the inevitable outcome of Romneycare?
Labels: skill-estate
Corporate personhood again
Earlier I made the point that proper leftists should be USING the idea that a corporation is a person, instead of trying to delete the idea. If a corporation has the same rights and responsibilities as a person, then you can prosecute a company for murdering other companies through LBOs or regulatory capture. LBO is direct murder, regulatory control is murder through a hitman impersonating a policeman.
Using the same literal connection might help to understand a couple of puzzles in recent years.
Puzzle 1: Why did insurance companies and pension funds allow ZIRP to happen? Insurers and pensions, taken together, are larger than the banks who gained from ZIRP. They have plenty of lobbyists. They could see EASILY that ZIRP would destroy them.
Puzzle 2: Why did insurers allow Obamacare to happen? Predicting business risk is their CORE SKILL. Why didn't they use it?
Puzzle 3: Why did football companies encourage their players to insult their OWN AUDIENCE for a year before they finally figured out the problem?
In personhood terms, all three are
intentional corporate SUICIDE. Why does a company ... or a whole class of companies .... voluntarily choose to lose its own profitability?
The standard myth of capitalism says that corporate persons are cold rational machines, acting solely to increase their own profits, while human beings are squishy irrational randomizers, acting on the basis of momentary hormone secretions.
I don't know if that was ever true, but it's completely backwards now.
Living people are no longer willing to die for a cause. All the causes that formerly commanded love and devotion have betrayed us and fucked us over and over and over and over. Fuck them.
This rational cynicism doesn't apply among corporate persons, who are still romantically ready to die for SOMETHING. In these specific cases the SOMETHING seems to be Deepstate, but I don't think that's necessarily the only True Faith or True Lover.
Labels: the broken circle
Yeah, still harping on this
When attempting to solve serious problems, it's always wise to sort the problems into quick-n-easy solutions and hard solutions. If there's a quick-n-easy, DO IT NOW.
Among our economic problems, outsourcing and immigration have been building up for 40 years, and will take a long time to unravel. Even if we do the RIGHT thing by shooting all the serial-killer capitalists, confiscating their criminal wealth, and imposing a Soviet-style
Gosbank system, it would still take a few years to rebuild factories and skills.
ZIRP/QE is the quick-n-easy one. It isn't a broad long-standing agreement by many murderers and gangsters; it's a RECENT SINGLE DECISION by ONE agency. It could be undone INSTANTLY by deleting the central bank and shooting all of its employees.
So where does ZIRP/QE stand in the priorities of our alleged 'radicals'? Bernie never touched it. Trump mentioned it once, but now he's falling in line with the Deep State as I feared. The Legalize Pot Party, especially the Pauls, had made an issue of "auditing" the Fed, which would do nothing at all; but now the LP has chosen candidates who are even Deeper State than Hillary.
As always I'm puzzled by this. Outsourcing/immigration achieves a pure Deep State goal without any conflicts. Kills the poor, enriches the Chosen plus even some non-Chosen rich. It's easy to see why the Deep State loves this range of murder methods.
ZIRP kills the responsible
middle class and benefits SOME of the rich but also kills another section of the rich. It benefits hedge funds and investment banks and kills insurers and pension funds. Why didn't those BIG companies with LOTS of lobbyists try to stop it? Are all insurers owned by the wrong ethnic group? Is it that simple? The correct tribal casino
pushing out the incorrect tribal casino? Could be, but seems unlikely.
Labels: skill-estate, Гром победы
Corollaries of simplicity
I wanted to leave
previous item SIMPLE and harsh.
Here are a couple of corollaries.
1. The simple choice isn't even an XOR, an exclusive either-or. It's not a choice between saving the expected-to-die crowd VERSUS saving everyone else. The lockdowns have eliminated normal medical care, so many of the expected-to-die crowd will die of their existing problems whether they get the Branded Flu or not. Some hospitals and medical practices are closing permanently, so the expecteds are
going to die faster from now on.
2. And it's not just the closed hospitals. The stress and uncertainty are also killing more of the expecteds, along with everyone else. Confidence and normalcy and sleep and good diet are crucial for survival, especially for oldies. I'm 70 and mentally strong, with solid knowledge of REAL immunity and REAL public health, but avoiding the panic is GODDAMNED HARD WORK.
3. This ties into a
broad question I've been asking ever since the 2008 TARP coup. What happened to insurers? Insurance companies are big and rich, with lots of lobbyists and influence in state and federal government. In previous decades insurers used their bully power to improve real public health and real safety, especially with consumer products and automobiles.
They should have lobbied hard against ZIRP in 2008, because it would clearly and obviously ruin them. (Along with a lot of oldies.) But they didn't.
Now the actuaries should have been lobbying hard against the lockdowns, because actuaries understand EXPECTED TO DIE better than anyone else. They also understand the
perfectly predictable consequences of shutting down the whole fucking economy. But they didn't.
Labels: coot-proofing, Jackboot stomping forever
Transparent shared lies
Shared lies have been around as long as political partisanship. Both parties agree on a false definition of the problem. Party A says this is good, Party B says this is bad. Neither side is valid because they're talking about a delusion.
Most shared lies are hard to detect because the truth is either officially secret or tangled in layers of obfuscation and conventional wisdom. Among this year's lies, Bitcoin is a good example of both. One side says it's the salvation of the universe because it's untraceable, the other side says it's a tool for criminals because it's untraceable. In fact it's perfectly traceable. It has all the signs of a sting by Deepstate. Get the criminals and terrorists to use a "private" and "untraceable" currency that passes directly through NSA. Another hint is the mysterious Satoshi. His biography says CIA if you know the inside jokes. But nobody has OFFICIALLY AND DIRECTLY DECLARED that Bitcoin is a sting, so the shared lie is halfway plausible.
There's a new element in recent years. It showed up first with QE/ZIRP. Bugsy Bernanke DECLARED OPENLY AND PUBLICLY that the purpose of QE was solely to boost stock prices.
After he said this, both sides continued assuming that QE was supposed to improve the economy. Some said it was helping, some said it wasn't helping and needed even more QE. Nobody listened to the FOUNDER'S PUBLIC AND CANDID ADMISSION of what he was doing.
Same thing happened with Obamacare. The project was perfectly clear from the start. No mystery. The purpose of Obamacare is to grant a forcible total monopoly to insurers who already had a strong natural monopoly. When you increase a monopoly you get higher prices and worse service. Obamacare has delivered on that ACTUAL promise PERFECTLY from the start.
Neither side touched the plain and obvious truth. Both worked from a bizarre assumption that Obamacare was "socialized medicine". R said this was bad, D said it was good.
This year's minor adjustment continues the tradition. The R side PUBLISHED THE ACTUAL BILL, which was easy to read. It doesn't remove the mandate, it doesn't remove the double cost for no benefit, it only adds EVEN MORE SUBSIDIES for the insurers who were the sole beneficiary of the original program.
THIS WAS NOT SECRET. Nevertheless, both sides have operated on the bizarre delusion of "repeal and replace", or "gutting Obamacare". R says this is good, D says this is bad.
The alternative media are no help on these open lies. They just take one of the side-lies.
Labels: Shared Lie
Criminals getting tired of crime?
Interesting observation by one of the money-talkers on radio. Stepping back from the idiocy of politics, one big trend is starting to show up. Central banks are finally getting tired of ZIRP/QE. They haven't turned back toward honest economics yet, but it looks like they're starting to remove the lock from the steering wheel. This week, the central banks of Japan, China, Canada, Australia, England, and US all indicated that they were not going to take
further steps toward ZIRP/QE.
If this trend continues and accelerates until we resume honest uncontrolled interest rates and comparatively stable money supplies, a whole lot of problems will be solved without the interference of politics. Savers will start to spend again. Pension funds and insurers can start to recover. Borrowers (including stock speculators and governments) will have to slow down. Banks will realize they can't just sit there and suck Janet's titties; they will have to start being banks again. They will have to pay for deposits and make cautious loans. Investors may consider using their money productively, though that's the least likely part of this extrapolation.
Demand-side
As stunningly tiny numbers continue to emerge from Romneycare, maybe it's time to ask a non-technical question.
Murkowski announced today that the Alaska version of the Romneycare Connector has so far enrolled EXACTLY THREE customers.
The federal version is still successfully enrolling DOZENS of people toward a presumed goal of 47 million.
Is this a technical problem? Supply restricted by website problems? Or is it simply that NOBODY WANTS THIS WHOLE FUCKING MESS?
Romneycare was NOT passed in response to popular demand. I had assumed that the insurers wanted it, but more recent info shows that they weren't excited about the idea. Only Joe Lieberman wanted it, and he doesn't need it.
Somewhat parallel to the criminal justification for QE and TARP and all that. Supposedly those counterfeiting projects were meant to loosen up credit, but borrowing for business investment hasn't increased despite zero interest rates.
Among the many absurd assumptions of economics is the notion that "everything will sell at the right price." This is obviously untrue in real life. Some houses and cars and jobs and employees and spouses remain untaken regardless of price or inducements.
ZIRP and Romneycare are good examples of the failed assumption. Even at zero interest, businesses don't want to borrow. Even with LOW! LOW! LOW! subsidized rates for "the right customers", people don't want this type of insurance. I sure as fucking shit don't want my ENTIRE FUCKING MONTHLY EXPENSES TO INCREASE BY 20 FUCKING PERCENT FOR EXACTLY NO FUCKING BENEFIT.